Kategorie: News
Verdict stands: Captain Jerry Boylan must serve prison sentence for fire that killed 34 people
A U.S. federal appeals court has upheld the conviction of Jerry Boylan, captain of the dive boat Conception. The 71-year-old former ship's officer had already been found guilty in November 2023 of committing “misconduct, negligence, or carelessness by a ship's officer” – a legal basis known as “manslaughter by a seaman.” In May 2024, Boylan was sentenced to four years in federal prison. With the appeals court's decision, his sentence is now final and he must begin serving his time.
The background to the case was the devastating fire aboard the Conception in the early hours of September 2, 2019, when the 23-meter boat was anchored off Santa Cruz Island off the California coast. The fire claimed the lives of 34 people: 33 passengers and one crew member. Numerous pieces of evidence presented during the trial indicated that the victims died of smoke inhalation and suffocation while trying to escape from the enclosed area below deck. A short video taken by a trapped passenger documented the desperate struggle for survival just minutes after the fire broke out.
The charges against Boylan were based on several violations of federal safety regulations. According to the court, the Conception's crew had not received proper fire safety training, and no night watch had been established. Further evidence showed that Boylan alerted the US Coast Guard but did not use the ship's public address system to wake passengers sleeping below deck before leaving the boat. Court findings suggest that the emergency exits were blocked, trapping many passengers as they tried to escape.
After the conviction, Boylan's lawyers requested a new trial and appealed the case. They argued that the jury had been given incorrect instructions. Specifically, they objected that the jury had been informed that Boylan could be convicted if he had acted “wrongfully and/or with gross negligence.” In the defense's view, this wording lowered the bar for a conviction below the standard required by law.
Misconduct, negligence, or carelessness
Before the three-judge appeals court, Judge John B. Owens ruled against this view. In his written opinion, he stated that the relevant law did not require proof of gross negligence. Rather, it criminalizes deaths caused by “wrongdoing, negligence, or carelessness in the performance of his duties” by a ship's captain. Thus, the legal basis on which the conviction was based had not been misapplied.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Alexander Robbins pointed out during the trial that disagreements over the exact wording of the jury instructions had virtually no impact on the course of the trial. “It had no impact on the arguments, it had no impact on how the parties framed their arguments, it had no impact whatsoever,” Robbins said. “It was literally irrelevant to the jury's decision.”
“Verdict is correct”
The confirmation of the verdict means a kind of “legal closure” for the victims' families. Relatives welcomed the appeals court's decision. Maggie Strom, whose husband Ted died in the disaster, said she was not surprised by the confirmation of the original conviction. She considered the verdict of negligent homicide of 34 people to be “correct.” Clark and Kathleen McIlvain, whose son Charles was among the dead, expressed relief and emphasized that Boylan had not spent a single day in prison; with the verdict now confirmed, he would finally be held accountable.
The Conception tragedy prompted not only legal but also regulatory changes in the US. After the fire, significant safety changes were mandated in the small passenger ship industry. The new measures include the requirement for nighttime fire watches and improved escape and fire detection systems to reduce the risk of similar disasters recurring.
The appeals court's decision ends an important legal process in this case: the conviction for breach of duty as ship captain stands, and Boylan must serve the prison sentence imposed. For the victims' families, this is a step toward a final answer to the question of responsibility for one of the deadliest accidents in recent US shipping history.
Further information:
(Articles in German language)
California: Fire on dive safari ship - several dead
34 fatalities in nighttime fire on dive ship “Conception” off the coast of California
Preliminary investigation completed: New details on the “Conception” disaster
Captain of the diving boat Conception charged
Facebook post (Sep 2019) and comments on the disaster